Bf26 site mobile 600x250@2x
Jason and lucia gta 6

Is ‘GTA 6’ the Greatest Video Game of All Time? The Reviews Are In

Eleni Thomas
By Eleni Thomas - News

Updated:

Readtime: 5 min

Every product is carefully selected by our editors and experts. If you buy from a link, we may earn a commission. Learn more. For more information on how we test products, click here.

Gamers, the time has finally arrived. After what has felt like decades of waiting, Rockstar’s GTA 6 is finally live. After more than a decade of rumours, speculation, and the odd delay, Rockstar’s new open-world adventure is here.

While anticipated video games have been released in the past few years, nothing has come close to rivalling the build-up around this release. Can you name another time there was such a spike in sick leave for a cultural moment? There was never any doubt the game would be good. However, critics cannot contain their excitement or praise for this new title. From its sprawling open world and cinematic storytelling to its impressive technical achievements, there’s plenty for critics to get excited about. But is it genuinely worth the wait? We’ve rounded up what the gaming world’s biggest publications have to say.

Before we dive in, it’s worth highlighting that review aggregators don’t necessarily tell the whole story. Different publications have their own unique scoring systems. What’s more, Metacritic (the gaming equivalent of Rotten Tomatoes for the cinephiles reading this) uses a weighted calculation rather than a straightforward average.

GTA 6 Review Scores: What Are the Critics Saying?

It’s safe to say that the early verdict for GTA 6 is overwhelmingly positive. As soon as the embargo lifted, GTA VI skyrocketed to the very top of the Metacritic charts with a score of 99/100 on PlayStation 5. Similarly, the game also sits at the very top of OpenCritic, with an average critic score of 99.

To give a broader look at how gaming critics are reacting to the release of GTA, here is how some of the biggest gaming publications worldwide have rated Rockstar’s latest blockbuster.

PublicationReview Score
IGN10/10
GameSpot10/10
Game Informer10/10
TechRadar5/5
Push Square10/10
Eurogamer5/5
GamesRadar+5/5
The Guardian5/5
VGC5/5
Scroll horizontally to view full table

If the above roundup of reviews doesn’t give you insight into how quickly GTA 6 has entered legendary gaming status, I don’t know what will.

Gta 6 reviews underwter
Image: Rockstar Games

What Are Critics Saying About GTA 6?

If there is one thing that almost all GTA 6 reviews can’t seem to stop talking about, it’s the world Rockstar has created. Vice City is already an iconic location within the GTA franchise, but this newest entry has raised the stakes and Vice City’s legacy to almost immeasurable heights. 

This is definitely what stood out to me most after playing through the early hours of the game. Leonida is a sprawling playground packed with bustling city streets, sun-soaked beaches, sprawling wetlands and countless opportunities to get yourself into trouble. Vice City is once again the centrepiece, but the surrounding environments give the experience enormous variety.

From random NPC encounters to seemingly insignificant environmental details, there’s an impressive amount happening beyond the main storyline. Even after dozens of hours, players are apparently still discovering new activities and interactions.

Other major talking points that almost all critics have been spotlighting in their reviews are:

  • The relationship between Jason and Lucia brings a new emotional dimension to the franchise
  • Rockstar has raised the bar for open-world games once again
  • The technical achievement is impressive despite GTA 6 being locked at 30 FPS
Gta 6 reviews background
Image: Rockstar Games

What Are Critics Complaining About? GTA 6 Negatives

Even though there appears to be nothing but praise for GTA 6, critics did raise a few minor points as negatives. First and foremost, post-release reviews highlighted the slow pacing, particularly during the game’s opening hours. Having played through the beginning myself, I also understand these concerns.

Others have pointed towards familiar Rockstar gameplay quirks, including occasionally clunky controls and a few repetitive action sequences. The game’s trademark humour has also attracted some criticism. While Rockstar’s irreverent approach to satire remains a defining characteristic of the series, some reviewers feel certain jokes haven’t aged particularly well.

Gta 6 reviews artwork
Image: Rockstar Games

Is GTA 6 the Best Video Game Ever Made?

It’s certainly making a convincing argument. From what I’ve played so far, I completely understand why this rhetoric is being thrown around less than two days after the game’s release.

Critical acclaim isn’t the only defining factor in the GOAT video game discussion. Important factors such as sales and legacy play an equally important role. Whether GTA 6 ultimately earns its place as the greatest game of all time will depend on how players respond over the coming months and years.

The 10 Highest-Rated Video Games of All Time

The release of GTA 6 marks the biggest shake-up to the highest-ranking games list we’ve seen since Nintendo’s Breath of the Wild over a decade ago. With GTA 6 now sitting at the top of the leaderboard, here is a quick recap of the top 10 games of all time, according to Metacritic.

Rank Video GameMetaScore
1Grand Theft Auto VI 99
2The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time99
3SoulCalibur98
4Super Mario Galaxy 298
5Grand Theft Auto IV98
6Super Mario Galaxy97
7Grand Theft Auto V97
8The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild97
9Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 97
10Perfect Dark97
Scroll horizontally to view full table

You may notice a few other GTA games on this list. However, GTA 6 has managed to outdo its predecessors – no small feat, given that both GTA V and GTA IV were also greatly praised upon release.

Gta 6 reviews protagonists
Image: Rockstar Games

Final Thoughts

GTA 6 has arrived with an extraordinary critical reception, and Rockstar appears to have delivered one of the most ambitious gaming experiences ever created. Whether you’re a longtime fan of the franchise or a newcomer looking for your next obsession, Leonida is absolutely a world you will get lost in.

The longer I play GTA 6, the more I understand why and how this title deserves such unanimous praise. To call it a generational title almost seems too small a statement, as there is no doubt GTA 6’s impact will remain pivotal for years to come.

For more GTA content, check out Man of Many’s guide to the in-game soundtrack & radio stations, plus how you can buy a real-life GTA 6 Supercar.

Eleni Thomas

Contributor

Eleni Thomas

Eleni is an Australian journalist with a love for all things video games and pop culture. Having completed her Bachelor of Journalism at RMIT University in Melbourne, Eleni currently writes full time for entertainment out Dexerto as well as across ...

Comments

We love hearing from you. or to leave a comment.

No comments yet. Be the first to give your opinion!

Trending Stories